Human Rights

Central Asian migrants describe injustice, racism in Russia

By Arman Kaliyev


Men from poor Kyrgyz villages on June 30 sit on a bench in Bishkek, waiting for offers of temporary work like repairs, construction or unloading of carts. Most Kyrgyz prefer to look for work in the capital rather than going to Russia, where life for migrants is worsening every day. [Arman Kaliyev]

BISHKEK -- Russian law enforcement bodies are systematically violating the rights of Central Asian migrants and subjecting them to violence and extortion, human rights activists say.

Central Asian migrants who shared their stories with Caravanserai spoke about life in Russia, which for many of them has turned into a "nightmare".

The Russian people have a negative attitude towards migrants, while Russian police hunt them down, say the migrants.

Hostility every day

Mairambek Osmonov, 33, in March returned to his hometown of Sokuluk, Kyrgyzstan, from Moscow. He was one of many Central Asian migrants who went to Russia with the hope of supporting his family. Now he works as a driving instructor in Bishkek.


Human rights activist Valentina Chupik (centre) talks to citizens of Central Asian countries in this undated photo. [Facebook]

Residents of Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan often choose to go to Russia because they speak Russian. Their linguistic knowledge enables them to take low-status positions that locals reject -- such as construction workers, freight handlers, janitors, guards and similar occupations.

Russia is supposed to give citizens of Kyrgyzstan preferential treatment because both countries belong to the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU), a regional economic bloc co-ordinated by Moscow, Osmonov said. In theory, shared EEU membership guarantees Kyrgyz the right to live and work unhindered anywhere in Russia.

"However, in fact, Russian officials demonstrate hostility toward us and make clear their displeasure with 'uninvited' guests from Central Asia," he said.

He swore he would never return to Russia.

"Even if we could stand the unfriendliness of Russians toward us, the police, who literally rob and degrade us, don't let us live in peace," he told Caravanserai. "It's better that I earn less but [at least] in my own country."

Osmonov said that in Moscow he had to hide from law enforcement all the time even though his documents were all in order.

Police officers used to illegally confiscate his documents and would return them only after he bribed them, he said.

"When I saw a patrol car, I usually ducked into the nearest [apartment] courtyard," he said. "They easily figure out their victims -- a Kyrgyz or an Uzbek. For them, we're a cash cow."

Large-scale human rights violations

Police officers in Russia take documents from migrants as a form of extortion, said Valentina Chupik of Moscow, executive director of Tong Jahoni, an international human rights organisation.

Police take the documents to "sell" them back to migrants. If they take a migrant to a police station, "buying back" the documents costs about four times as much, she told in May.

Chupik described detention centres where Central Asian migrants are usually kept as "concentration camps".

"The person is put into a basement, a cubicle, a tiny cell, without any furniture, with vermin, without food or water or the chance to go to the bathroom," she said. "They take their phones away ... [and] ... hold them for days, so that the migrants want to ransom themselves."

She told about a shocking case in which Russian police neglect almost killed a diabetic Kyrgyz migrant worker.

Patrolmen detained the man as he left a pharmacy after purchasing insulin. Even though his documents were in order, they hauled him to the police station. They took away his insulin and threw him into a cell for a day and a half.

He went into a diabetic coma.

"Do you think that the police called paramedics? No. They took the guy out and put him on a bench; then they went to a court where the judge, without looking [at the documents], stamped a decision to deport him," Chupik said.

"The young man did not regain consciousness until the second day and he was in critical condition," she said.

Increasing violence, corruption

"Police in Russia are the most corrupt agency [in the country]," said Chupik, a specialist on immigration policy with a focus on providing free legal and social aid for migrants. "Nazism is cultivated in the police for the purpose of extracting corrupt income."

Chupik herself moved from Uzbekistan to Moscow, where she provides free assistance to migrant workers who have had trouble with the police.

She gets about 40 calls per day, the majority of which are complaints about illegal detention.

"If a migrant is not a blue-eyed blond, particularly if his eyes have an Asian slant, a policeman will stop him," she said, noting that law enforcement personnel do not have the right to detain migrants without cause.

Studies monitoring migrants' rights in Russia have shown growing violence by law enforcement agencies and corruption appearing under the pretext of fighting extremism and terrorism, according to Tolekan Ismailova of Bishkek, vice president of the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH).

"Migrants [in Russia] are having their ... freedom of movement and freedom of choice of residence taken away from them," she told Caravanserai.

The intimidation and raids directed by police against Central Asian migrants make clear the large-scale violations of human rights and civil liberties in Russia, added Ismailova.

Do you like this article?

6 Comment(s)

Comment Policy * Denotes Required Field 1500 / 1500

russia is full of brain dead slobs that think theyre truly european colonialists while it was the slavs that got railed by europe and the us, the real europeans. Russia wishes they could claim the glory but they are really uneducated and ignorant. I mean really, which group of people, dress up as nazis (whom their grandfathers and fathers died against in war) and think theyre some how european? lol then become racist against others? LOL slavs are hilarious (not real white), hitler even said so lol


Oh, this is interesting. But why don't you tell about their behaviour in Russia and how they treated Russians in the 90s forcing them to leave their homes and flee to Russia?


Yes, it's true, and it's been getting much worse over the years! Why would we need a strategic partner like this, if [they] treat us like rubbish and use as slaves to achieve their geopolitical and geo-economic objectives! There's nothing left from the CIS and if Central Asia turns away from Russia, then Russia will remain all alone with its deaf ears!


You will be treated good if you behave like humans. But when in Rome you don't like to do as the Romans do. Don't complain then. Sit home if you can't be human.


Good point. If you want to live in Russia, accept and respect the culture of this country.


Ruslan, it's more important that Russia wouldn't turn away from you. There are lots of wiseguys like you, but so many of you work and live in Russia actually. If it was so bad, no one would come looking for work in Russia.