https://central.asia-news.com/en_GB/articles/cnmi_ca/features/2019/03/11/feature-02
| Human Rights

Kremlin evades historical facts of devastating 1930s famine in Kazakhstan

By Kanat Altynbayev

image

The Ana (Mother) sculpture, a monument to the victims of the 1931–1933 famine in Kazakhstan, was erected in Almaty in 2017. [Kanat Altynbayev]

ALMATY -- Fear of historical responsibility is the reason for a recent attempt by the Russian Foreign Ministry to whitewash a tragedy of the 1930s in Central Asia, say observers.

On February 22, the ministry posted an official statement "on insinuations surrounding the tragedy caused by famine in the Soviet Union in 1932–1933".

"Supporters of nationalist views" in Central Asia are imposing on their compatriots the claim that the Soviet government organised a genocide of their ancestors, claimed the ministry.

One reason for Moscow's nervous reaction is a documentary by Almaty journalist Zhanbolat Mamai, "Zulmat: Genocide in Kazakhstan" about the tragic events in Kazakhstan during that period. Zulmat is a Kazakh word for tragedy or catastrophe.

image

A woman with a child is shown in the early 1930s in Kazakhstan. [Kazakh Central State Archive of Film, Photo and Audio Documents]

image

Kazakhs are shown trekking to China sometime in the 1930s to escape the famine from forced collectivisation. [Screenshot from the film "Zulmat: Genocide in Kazakhstan"]

The documentary was screened January 30 in Almaty and drew an audience of more than 2,000 viewers. On YouTube, it has had more than 418,000 views so far and garnered more than 7,400 comments.

The film tells how the forced collectivisation of agriculture raged in Kazakhstan in the late 1920s and early 1930s. Starvation struck as Soviet troops seized grain from starving peasants, forced them and nomads onto collective farms, and killed or internally exiled the "kulaks", the more prosperous peasants, whom the regime declared a class enemy.

In "Zulmat", Mamai reveals the facts and the scale of the Kazakh tragedy -- neither of which have ever appeared in a single Soviet textbook.

"More than 3 million people died of starvation," he said in the film. "No war waged by the Kazakhs against foreign invaders took so many lives. This was a genocide in Kazakhstan that was orchestrated by the Bolshevik leaders."

Other sources offer different estimates of the death toll from the famine in Kazakhstan, with numbers ranging from 1.5 to 4 million victims.

More than a third of all Kazakhs died in the famine, turning the survivors into a minority in their own Soviet republic, according to the US historian Sarah Cameron. Thousands of Kazakhs found Soviet conditions so impossible that they fled to impoverished China.

Horror of the 1930s in Kazakhstan

The weight of the suffering landed much harder on the Kazakhs than on the ethnic Russians in Kazakhstan -- by the Kremlin's design, according to scholars.

When food aid came from abroad, Soviet authorities sent it only to ethnic Russian communities in Kazakhstan and steered it away from the Kazakhs, Kaidar Aldajumanov, a senior researcher at the Institute of History and Ethnology in Almaty, said in the film.

Mamai, in his documentary, also cited the Soviet use of air power against Kazakhs who rose up against the regime at that time. The pilots who bombed their own compatriots were declared Heroes of the Soviet Union, the country's highest decoration.

Joseph Stalin's regime collectivised agriculture to destroy private property, Anuar Galiyev, a history professor at the Al-Farabi Kazakh National University in Almaty, told Caravanserai.

In addition, "the Soviet authorities were trying to build a Communist world revolution, and to do this they exported grain and livestock ... to finance the construction of defence factories," Galiyev said.

Other goals of seizing grain and livestock by force included feeding the cities and the Red Army, even though rural dwellers (including the reviled kulaks) had nothing left for themselves; shattering the pastoral nomadism that many Kazakhs still practiced; and equipping the collective farms that turned peasants and former nomads into apathetic labourers with no profit motive.

The famine of the 1930s drove up the death rate in Soviet regions that grew grain and raised livestock, such as Kazakhstan, Ukraine and the Volga region of Russia, Nadejda Atayeva of Le Mans, France, president of the Association for Human Rights in Central Asia, told Caravanserai.

"This tragedy occurred because of the inhuman economic policy of the Soviet-era Communists," she said.

"The majority of the information held by the NKVD [the forerunner of the KGB] about these events remains classified," Atayeva added.

Archival materials prove deliberate genocide

The Foreign Ministry, in its February 22 statement, sought to hide the devastating truth.

The famine had natural causes, such as a drought and crop failure, and was compounded by "emergency measures that made things worse", in the Kremlin's delicate phrasing. The Soviet government had enacted emergency relief by 1933, said the Foreign Ministry.

"We are convinced that manipulation of historical facts by using the 'nationalist card' will not succeed in deceiving the peoples of Central Asia, who have a brotherly bond with Russians," added the Foreign Ministry.

Even after the passage of more than 80 years, Russia is trying to conceal the Stalin regime's purposeful creation of the famine, Mamai told Caravanserai.

"Russia is threatening to use archival documents to prove the opposite," he added, calling the Kremlin line on the famine "an outright lie".

"Archival materials stored in Kazakhstan confirm the occurrence of the genocide in Kazakhstan," said Mamai. "However, the Kremlin classified important archival materials."

Those Kremlin-held documents, if exposed, would force Moscow to "admit the greatest crime of the Soviet government", he said.

Russia fears historical responsibility and is trying to shift attention on to the individuals raising this sensitive topic, said Atayeva the human rights activist.

"The Russian government is becoming a hostage of its own policy of silence," she said, adding that the policy would only backfire and that "people's desire to learn the truth will only grow".

A democratic society requires the creation of all the conditions enabling a historical and legal evaluation of such events, she said.

"At that point, the nationalist subtext that Russia is using for propaganda purposes will fall away," she said.

Do you like this article?
173
No
55 Comment(s)
Comment Policy
Captcha

The Holodomor was real, my great-grandmother saved all the kids in her whole village from starvation! They remembered her till her last breath. She cooked oats in a large pot :(( Ural province, Kuskul village.

Reply

I heard about the horrors of the Holodomor in Russia, Ukraine, and Kazakhstan from eyewitnesses as early as the Soviet times. And I consider it a crime against humanity. However, the problem is that the latest Genocide Convention of 1948 is equivocal. Namely, the USSR forced the removal of killings on the basis of class and social status from the initial draft leaving only racial and religious motives. So, let's not forget that a lot of legal documents are the result of a political compromise and should not be referred to as holy writ. The USSR was guilty as sin, so it took care of getting an indulgence for itself. Otherwise, this convention would not have been signed.

Reply

I've seen for all my life since 1960 that living in Kazakhstan is better than in Russia.

Reply

The Holodomor is brainwashing the younger generation. Why would Americans care about Kazakhstan? They are simply trying to put their hands on it. And you are still whining. You think it would be better living under the Yanks. But the first thing they will do is make these false scholars shut up. And you all will be squashed by yankee democracy. People, learn to think independently. Read and analyse, don't gobble up everything you get from these "scholars"

Reply

What do you really know about our history? An elder told me personally about these events.

Reply

Rossiya oppressed Muslims a lot

Reply

My mother told me in the 70s that all the horses in [her] village were seized, driven into a ditch and shot with machine guns. After that they brought kerosene and soaked carcasses so that hungry Kazakhs couldn't eat. Don't tell me that famine wasn't organised. Recalling the famine she said it turned out Russians couldn't bear starvation.

Reply

Bastards!!!
Russia will have to answer for its heinous crimes sooner or later. So many Kazakhs were killed. And before that they annihilated the nation's light and elite. They destroyed Alash's autonomy and its people. [a state that existed on the territory of Kazakhstan in 1917-1918]

Reply

There's a proof of the Holodomor. All the bastards of the time like Goloshchyokin seized everything. He cabled Stalin that the they were treating the locals punishingly. [Filipp Goloshchyokin, First Secretary of the Communist Party in the Kazakh Autonomous Socialist Soviet Republic (1925-1933)]

Reply

Stepan Bandera was a hero, not a criminal. Respectfully.

Reply

There was no genocide whatsoever

Reply

Don't confuse hunger with the Holodomor [starvation]. When rich folks go on a diet they don't eat too but it has nothing in common with the Holodomor which was a deliberate genocide of the two largest ethnic groups. The USSR and Stalin were criminals.

Reply

Famine is a fact, denying this is foolish. THERE WAS NO GENOCIDE! As well as there was no Holodomor [starvation] in Ukraine they are trying to portray as the genocide, this time of Ukrainians. Hunger was common in the beginning of the 20th century. The US famine in the early 30s is a good example.
"We ate whatever was available as we had to change our usual diet. We used to eat bush leaves instead of cabbage. We ate frogs. My mother and my older sister died in a month." (Jack Griffin)
In a decade from 1931 to 1940 the USA lost 8,553,000 people because of decreased population growth. And this is just official statistics that is strictly avoided. What's more is population growth dropped in an instant, exactly twofold (!!!) at the beginning of 1931. It plummeted and remained unchanged for ten years precisely.
But any competent demographer would tell you such a drastic decrease in population growth in a huge country of 100 million people could only happen as a result of mass deaths. And now tell me, have you ever heard about the GENOCIDE of the American people? No! Because for them this famine is some kind of force majeure precipitated by the Great Depression. But in the USSR it's a genocide, of course!

DOUBLE, TRIPLE, TENFOLD AMERICAN STANDARDS MAKE ME SICK ALREADY!
___

All the potshots at the USSR do not hold water and disappear if confronted with facts. Besides, blaming the USSR today is simply vulgar

Reply

You're wrong. In the beginning the Soviet leaders were ignorant. They learned and were taught eventually, so things had started to change for the better. Many Kazakh schools had been closed at the time, there was only one Kazakh school among many Russian schools in [the city of] Karaganda with a population of 500,000 people. So you can see that they tried to get rid of the Kazakh language, customs, and traditions.

Reply

That's true...... By 1958, there were only Kazakh boarding schools left for children from the remote rural areas...... City kids could go only to Russian schools...... I'm from Karaganda......

Reply

Russia is the most criminal country. It has no honour.

Reply

Correct!

Reply

Oh, yes! They are going to any lengths to sow discord. This propaganda from the West is so obvious.

Reply

Kremlin terrorists will never confess unless there's a trial.

Reply

One of the reasons for inciting ethnic hatred is to sow doubts in a multi-ethnic country and destroy an already fragile state.

Reply

Gentlemen!
Russia also suffered from famine - my grandmother's three children died of starvation. Jews were raging. They covered themselves under pseudo-Russian surnames.
And Jews had seized power in Ukraine.
Think.

Reply

You write that Kazakhstan was a Soviet republic, but put the blame on Russia. Nonsense. Besides, a Georgian [Stalin] ruled the USSR.

Reply

Kazakhstan was forced to join the USSR.

Reply

Russia is essentially a cannibalistic country. It never admits to its crimes. Therefore its collapse and punishment would be only just.

Reply

Another article by the American ass-kissers... Paid-for propaganda as much as others... A bit later you will feel what "American style freedom" means... Nazarbaev was the last leader raised by the Soviet system you hate so much. Dark days are looming all over the world. However, our (post-Soviet) countries will suffer more. "Thanks" to our modern "liberal" leadership, sold out and intoxicated by this very "American freedom" destabilizing everything within its reach... Wishing all the best to everybody!!!

Reply

Facts are facts. Half of all Kazakhs died of starvation and it was the fault of the Soviet regime, simply because [the regime] seized livestock. As you know Kazakhs didn't do agriculture. Hence they were exterminated. And this is genocide.

Reply

Well, in your opinion America concocts everything. But what are you going to do with the facts in this article? Our grandfathers and grandmothers told us about these things when we were kids. Russia always thought first and foremost about itself. It is always willing to subdue its allies in order to show off its greatness and dominate. It gave others no chance. Before you talk crap about America, admit Russia is no better, if not much worse. [Russia] destroyed the history of the Asian countries to demonstrate their development without the USSR was impossible. Russia should be grateful to the Asian countries for its achievements. It's not just us who depends on you. You depend on us too. Your arrogance would not let you admit it. Don't base your opinion about World War 2 on the information from Russia only. Stop deceiving yourselves thinking you are great and the friendliest people. You don't care about your parents, let alone other nations.

Reply

For military and economic crimes (genocide, de-kulakization policy and forced famine of 1918-1944‘s), Aral disaster of 1960-1980‘s, forcing cotton mono-culture Russia has to pay many billions to the nations of Central Asia. We must bring this issue to the Hague tribunal.

Reply

Then you should pay Russia billions for the factories, machinery, universities, schools, for your borders, for the very existence of your people as well as for 19 million Russians and one million Central Asians killed in action during WW2 for you to write this sh.t now. But the common folk in Central Asia are fraternal people. Those like you are responsible for famine and other things. You are looking for excuses, you never work for the good of your countries, you can only cajole everything out of others and make a big stink from abroad.

Reply

What factories? Those factories were built to process raw materials and send them to Russia. Moscow stole everything from Kazakhstan. Destroyed half the people. Now who is making a stink? A billion rubles is not worth one human life. But here we are talking about at least 3 million Kazakhs!!!

Reply

Russians, confess! Take the burden of this sin off your shoulders. Otherwise God will make you pay for everything.

Reply

One can't blame every Russian for that. Today there's no one to be responsible for what happened then and the son shall not bear the sins of the father.

Reply

While people had been dying of starvation in Ukraine, Kazakhstan, they [the authorities] were carrying out industrialisation. And paid the West with grain instead of feeding their own population. That's a disgraceful crime.

Reply

Obvious filthy propaganda by our "Western partners" is evident here with the naked eye...

Reply

Every elder would tell you about those events without Western partners. [They] had simply suffered much and kept silent. There are very few eyewitnesses still with us today. But we, Kazakhs (I'm not sure about others), knew since we were kids that no breadcrumb should fall on the floor, although everyone lived well already... Nowadays when cakes are thrown in faces, it's such an abomination. So, with or without the West, people know this and it's important to educate our younger generation to make them remember.

Reply

Utter nonsense! Another piece of anti-Soviet bullshit! Learn history, then you will not be fooled by such crap...

Reply

What history? Soviet history? Haha, it's like a [Hans Christian] Andersen fairy tale...

Reply

"After famine in the 30s, which besides the USSR struck the Polish region of Ukraine, Czechoslovakia and Romania" - it's a lie!!! An attempt to hide the essence of the problem. There was no 20s-30s famine in the Polish region of Ukraine, nor in Czechoslovakia, Romania. But in the Soviet part of Ukraine famine had been created intentionally. Millions of people died... That's why it is an official Memorial day in Ukraine supported by the UN!

Reply

(Andrey Eremkin)

Reply to Eremkin.
You are distorting the facts in order to help the Kremlin "whitewash" [the tragedy]. This is not about Ukrainians as an ethnicity but about denizens of Ukraine of all nationalities in the late 20s - early 30s (Ukrainians, Russians, Jews, Germans, Bulgarians, Greeks...). In my granny's family only two out of eight children survived and later they had gone along with their exiled parents from Ukraine to Ural. This is the tragedy of those generations...

Reply

The US government apologised to Indians long ago and paid them compensations. Also, Indians living on their own lands are entitled to numerous benefits such as employment and education. And [Americans] don't deny the fact of committing genocide unlike Russia. Good for them

Reply

A film about the genocide of Indians in the USA is badly needed. I'm wondering what the reaction of Caravanserai's owners would be. After that genocide they, for example, didn't establish a Union of Iroquois, Apache, Mahican or Cherokee republics. They didn't teach schoolchildren in the Indian languages. They didn't even teach those languages. Ninety percent of Indians died off. And their numbers have never gotten back up. But Kazakhstan is now made up of 70% Kazakhs. The Soviets committed a rather strange genocide. After famine in the 30s, which, by the way, hit not just the USSR but also the Polish region of Ukraine, Czechoslovakia and Romania, they gave Kazakhstan republican status!

Reply

My grandparents fled Karaganda suburbs to Aulie Ata (Taraz) in 1929. Only two families out of 100 made it to the destination, my mother told me. Many people died on the road, they went there on foot having money in their pockets for livestock they were stripped of. They died of malnutrition in that town after a month of hunger. I witnessed my mother cry telling this story.

Reply

There were cases proving the genocide of Kazakhs. They delivered food in the areas where many Russians lived. And left Kazakhs to die.

Reply

My parents told me about the famine in great detail. My mother mentioned the culprits: Stalin, Goloshchekin.

Reply

That was a genocide under the guise of collectivisation

Reply

A terrible genocide

Reply

As far as I understand after reading this article, the Kremlin only denies the nationalist explanation of these tragic events. And the article reads, "the famine of the 1930s drove up the death rate in Soviet regions that grew grain and raised livestock, such as Kazakhstan, Ukraine and the Volga region of Russia". If that was a genocide of certain ethnic groups, how would you explain the famine in the Volga region? This is Russian soil, neither Ukrainian nor Kazakh. A genocide is defined as the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular ethnic, religious or social group. The ethnic explanation doesn't work here. It is rather social - the so-called "kulaks", more prosperous peasants [killed or exiled]. But Ukrainians keep calling it the Ukrainian genocide (although there were ethnic Russian and German peasants among them), and now Kazakhs telling the same thing about their people. It would be correct to call it the genocide of peasants opposing collectivisation. And this makes it easy to understand why Ukraine, the Volga region and Kazakhstan also suffered... [Are you trying] to define the civil war as an ethnic genocide?
This is not historical. Post factum assigning the roles of victims and persecutors? Propaganda and politisation... [that can easily] drown one in the Karpman drama triangle.
(Andrey Eremkin)

Reply

There were two episodes of famine in the Volga region in 1921-22 and in the 1930s. And if information about the drought [in the region] in the 20s had been confirmed, there was no such info about the 30s. The famine in the 30s had been organised intentionally. [The authorities] always sent food aid to the cities and never dispatched food to the rural population just like in the Volga region, namely in Bashkortostan and Tatarstan. They're not allowed to talk about that.

Reply

There was also another Holodomor [famine] in the Volga region, Moldova and Ukraine in 1946.

Reply

It is clear (1) this is not about genocide; (2) The son shall not bear the sins of the father; (3) Kazakhs enforced Bolshevist collectivisation themselves , among other things. Question: why are the authors sticking to their telltale ignorance?

Reply

The Soviet regime is a regime of cannibals

Reply

Russia itself and the USSR are the fruit of genocide. There are more Nazis in Russia than everywhere in Europe. Just give the go-ahead and Russians will go on a killing spree yet again!

Reply

Creation of the "genocide" myth is under way. Idiocy is going through the roof.

Reply

We must demand restitution from Russia for this genocide of the Kazakh people, like Israel demanded from Germany.

Reply

Would anyone expect anything different from the offspring of snitches and turnkeys.

Reply