Protests take aim at politicians urging Kyrgyz-Russian merger

By Kanat Altynbayev

A woman sells fruits on the side of a road in front of a campaign billboard for the Bir Bol (Stay Together) party in Koy-Tash village, 20km from Bishkek, September 30. [Vyacheslav Oseledko/AFP]

A woman sells fruits on the side of a road in front of a campaign billboard for the Bir Bol (Stay Together) party in Koy-Tash village, 20km from Bishkek, September 30. [Vyacheslav Oseledko/AFP]

BISHKEK -- Hundreds of Kyrgyz gathered in Bishkek last weekend to defend their country's sovereignty and denounce statements made by some politicians urging a merger of Kyrgyzstan with Russia.

The idea was upsetting to Kyrgyz who cherish their country's post-Soviet independence and were shocked to watch Russian troops illegally annex Crimea in 2014.

It would be equally unwelcome to resource-rich Kazakhstan, which would find itself sandwiched between parts of Russia if somehow the idea ever came to fruition. Kyrgyzstan has no border with Russia.

Users of social media networks organised the peaceful demonstration on September 27 ahead of parliamentary elections on Sunday (October 4), reported.

Russian President Vladimir Putin, right, shakes hands with his Kyrgyz counterpart, Sooronbay Jeenbekov, in Sochi, Russia, September 28. [Mikhail Klimentyev/SPUTNIK/AFP]

Russian President Vladimir Putin, right, shakes hands with his Kyrgyz counterpart, Sooronbay Jeenbekov, in Sochi, Russia, September 28. [Mikhail Klimentyev/SPUTNIK/AFP]

The protest comes after the recent posting on Facebook of a videotaped 2019 speech in Moscow by Kyrgyz member of parliament Marat Amankulov. In the video, he states that after almost 30 years of independence, Kyrgyzstan should integrate with Russia.

Amankulov is chairman of the Birimdik (Unity) party, which is viewed as loyal to President Sooronbay Jeenbekov and includes the president's brother and former parliamentary speaker, Asylbek Jeenbekov, among its candidates for parliament, AFP reported.

The mission of his party is to return the country to "Eurasianism", said Amankulov in the video, using a term popularised by Russian President Vladimir Putin and his circle.

"Thirty years of independence have shown us that it's time to come to our senses and go back," said Amankulov. "We have the same roots. Only a state that is united on the entire territory encompassing Eurasianism may be sovereign."

"We need to come together and be integrated. A life of freedom is good, but it's time to go home."

'Keep your hands off Kyrgyzstan'

Amankulov on September 26 denied the accusations against him, claiming he was speaking at a non-political event in Moscow.

However, Putin earlier this year spelled out the Kremlin's vision for a regathering of the former Soviet states under Moscow's control.

Putin on April 19 touted the "advantages" of restoring the Soviet Union.

"By conquering a phobia of the past and fears of a revival of the Soviet Union and of the Soviet empire ... the understanding that unification benefits everyone is inevitably prevailing," he said on state-owned television channel Russia-1.

Such statements by Putin and Amankulov are stirring anger among Kyrgyz citizens, many of whom see Amankulov as a puppet of the Kremlin and accused him of treason.

At the Bishkek protest, demonstrators held signs that said "For a free Kyrgyzstan", "Traitors, get out", "Kyrgyzstan will stay independent" and "Keep your hands off Kyrgyzstan".

Independence and freedom of speech in Kyrgyzstan are priceless and citizens need to fight for them, the leader of the demonstration in Bishkek's central square told protesters.

"In the 30 years since our country became independent from the Soviet Union, new, free Kyrgyz have been born. We will no longer get down on our knees," he said.

Politicians who support Kyrgyzstan joining Russia are sycophants, Kunduz Akmatova of Bishkek, a member of a Facebook group known as Independent Kyrgyzstan, posted on Facebook, referring to Amankulov.

"They dance to Putin's flute. We already sank in that swamp known as the Soviet Union for more than 70 years [1917-1991]. How many more can we take? Our country doesn't need sycophants but real reformers," Akmatova wrote.

The demonstration defending Kyrgyzstan's sovereignty reflects current trends in the country's political life, said analysts.

"The demonstration was emblematic in that the idea of national sovereignty, of its indisputable value and of its importance as a foundation of statehood and political self-determination are more actively spreading and taking root ... especially among the new generation of Kyrgyz politicians," said Askat Dukenbayev, a political analyst from Bishkek.

Dukenbayev expressed hope that the recent demonstration would become a "turning point in Kyrgyzstan's political life".

"Statements like these by prominent political figures in the country are unfortunate -- first and foremost for the politicians themselves -- because after they make such statements they look like lackeys of Putin's influence in Kyrgyzstan," he added.

Russian interference

Other Kyrgyz politicians have echoed Amankulov's provocative statements on a Kyrgyz-Russian merger.

The unification of Kyrgyzstan and Russia is a subject of discussion in both Kyrgyzstan and in the Kyrgyz diaspora in Russia, Raimkul Attokurov, a former Kyrgyz ambassador to Russia, told the online newspaper September 12.

"History has preordained us to be together. And considering what is happening with our friends the Belarusians, international strategic objectivity compels it," Attokurov said.

Abdygany Shakirov, the chairman of Kyrgyz Birimdigi (Kyrgyz Unity), the Kyrgyz diaspora organisation in Moscow, was quick to refute Attokurov's statement.

"We are authorised to state that in Kyrgyz Birimdigi, there has not been and there could not be discussion of our homeland becoming part of another country. We consider Raimkul Attokurov has no right to speak about this topic on behalf of the Kyrgyz living in Russia," Shakirov told September 14.

"He needs to put more value on Kyrgyzstan's sovereignty," said Shakirov.

A few days later, Attokurov told Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty (RFE/RL)'s Kyrgyz service that the Russian publication had distorted his words in the interview.

"Maybe [the Russian journalists] have their own agenda and interests," Attokurov suggested.

The two statements floating a possible Kyrgyz-Russian merger are connected, say some politicians.

Esen Momunkulov, a member of the Bir Bol (Stay Together) party and former director of the Investment Promotion and Protection Agency of the Kyrgyz Republic, said he was sure that the recent provocative statements by the Kyrgyz politicians were the result of efforts by Russian intelligence agencies.

"The independence of our country belongs to the people, not to politicians," he said.

Do you like this article?

12 Comment(s)

Comment Policy * Denotes Required Field 1500 / 1500

Our Czar has postponed financing your country. Burn our flag, vandalise the image of our leader... And then you will be dealt with like Armenia. And the question is whether we are going to help you at all. You have left the empire; live on. Why are you blaming it on us? We don't need your land; we have enough of our own.


Russia must stop assisting Kyrgyzstan altogether, and even if it keeps helping it should pointedly go to the diaspora only. Otherwise, the loans are embezzled, there's no result, and then an impoverished and drowning Russia writes off the debts owed by the rich and prosperous Kyrgyzstan. Russia will never annex anyone again unless they ask for it themselves; after all, they will ask for it. Just a bit longer, and the primordial Chinese lands (Kyrgyzstan) will go back home to China as collateral.


I completely support the protesters.


A protest should not be detrimental to the economy, but fighting for independence is justified.


Russia is under sanctions now. What would we board a sinking ship for?


The independence of Kyrgyzstan is above everything else. We don't want to join Russia.


Don't pile up how much you're worth. Why would Russia need this burden on its neck; as if they are in a hurry to merge you into [Russia]. Dream on 60190


I support the protesters completely. Not interested in this impoverished Russia.


What can I say? These are dumb, brainless liberals who have forgotten their history. Once upon a time, the Kyrgyz came to Russia asking them to pledge allegiance; and otherwise Kokandians and Chinese would have devoured them. Why are you busting your ass now? What sovereignty, for fuck's sake? You were bought and sold out lock, stock, and barrel long ago. Where are the more than 300 tons of gold from Kumtor? Where is the industry with a multitude of enterprises built over 30 years, not one abandoned oil refinery, and it was Chinese? Why are you begging the whole world for handouts, like lowlife beggars, and then run to Russia when anything happens? Get a cell for you X, and nothing but democracy


We don't need any union with Russia.


The union with Russia was what turned Central Asia from a feudal society into a civilized state. Russians helped build schools, universities, plants, and factories, and formed statehood there.


Enough lies - first you destroyed everything. Now you are rewriting history. Life has shown who's tribal here. With all your potential, you have reduced Russia to a gas station; you are kneeling before your Czar and destroying the environment in lands that never belonged to you. Keep living in the past, because the present doesn't need you.