Caravanserai
Society

Russian politicians try to paint Central Asian countries as 'oppressive'

By Kanat Altynbayev

image

Migrant workers from Uzbekistan renovate an area in a park in Sestroretsk, Russia, April 21, 2017. [Olga Maltseva/AFP]

ALMATY -- In the wake of isolated, trivial incidents, Russian officials are falsely accusing Central Asian countries of "oppressing and humiliating" their Russian-speaking populations.

It all began on August 2 in Bishkek, the Kyrgyz capital, when an intoxicated customer in a shopping centre became angry with a cashier who spoke to him in Russian instead of Kyrgyz. He threw a calculator at her.

The Bishkek police opened a case of disorderly conduct rather than assault, since the woman was not injured. However, Russian media trumpeted the incident as an example of the purported oppression of Russian-speaking citizens of Kyrgyzstan.

In an August 8 statement, the committee of the Russian Presidential Council for Civil Society and Human Rights called the event an "unfriendly action against our compatriots in Kyrgyzstan" and an "attempt to insult Russian speakers based on linguistic and ethnic attributes".

image

A store in Almaty, shown August 16, flouts Kazakh law by using a Russian-only sign. Moscow's politicians exaggerate the suffering of Russian minorities in Central Asia to score political points. [Kanat Altynbayev/Caravanserai]

The council then went so far as to claim that members of the Kyrgyz diaspora who work in Russia, supporting their families back home, do not face discrimination.

"The treatment of these people in Russia is in no way determined by their ethnicity or faith," the statement claimed.

The council urged Kyrgyz authorities to "investigate all incidents of oppression of our compatriots as soon as and as thoroughly as possible".

Russian lawmakers pounced on the incident.

In a protest he staged on August 10 outside the Kyrgyz embassy in Moscow, Vladimir Zhirinovsky, a member of the Russian State Duma, voiced threats to throw Kyrgyz migrants out of Russia and send them back to their homeland.

"One Russian was punched in the face, so send 10,000 Kyrgyz home. They'll be stuck with no jobs and no money," Zhirinovsky said.

"All sorts of bastards taunt and kill Russians all across the post-Soviet space, from Ukraine to Central Asia. How much of this will we put up with?" he shouted.

State Duma members Vyacheslav Volodin and Leonid Slutsky made similar caustic statements.

The furor compelled the Kyrgyz Foreign Ministry to react.

On August 10, Kyrgyz Foreign Minister Ruslan Kazakbayev discussed the matter with Russian Ambassador to Kyrgyzstan Nikolay Udovichenko and said that "Russian authorities should not interpret isolated incidents... as systematic violations of the rights and interests of ethnic Russians in Kyrgyzstan or as the oppression of citizens based on ethnic and religious attributes".

"In Kyrgyzstan, there is no Russophobia or any other form of aggressive nationalism, there is no rewriting of history, or battles with monuments or the Russian language," Kazakbayev said, pointing out that Russian is an official language in his country.

Kazakbayev asked the Russian ambassador to "draw the attention of certain Russian politicians to the unacceptability of biting statements about such problems and pronouncing them in the public arena in order to please specific provocative constituents".

Migrants outraged

The response from Russia has outraged Kyrgyz migrant workers in the country, who call the incident in Bishkek trivial compared to the torments that they encounter every day in Russia.

"It's no secret how migrants from Central Asia are treated. I'm not even talking about bullies, but people in positions of authority in Russia -- police who illegally lock migrants up if they don't have money for bribes, and beat them up," said Ulan Omorov of Tokmok, Chui province, Kyrgyzstan, who works in a Moscow supermarket.

"Who are they to talk about nativist thugs?"

Russia has many radical nationalists who lie in wait for migrants in the subway and dark alleys and beat them up for having darker skin and eyes with a different shape, said Omorov.

"Why are Russian human rights activists and politicians hiding this problem?" he asked.

The discrimination in Russia is apparent to more than just migrants.

"When someone arrives in Russia from Central Asia, he's treated like a second-class citizen from the moment he reaches passport control at the airport," Ilya Varlamov, a world traveller from Moscow who posts videos to YouTube about life in other countries, wrote on his Telegram channel.

"The Russian border guards... insult them by using the familiar 'you', they raise their voices and they're rude," he added.

For the border guards, Central Asians are "churki" (a racist insult), he said.

In Russia, slights and insults befall even Russians of Asian origin, not just Central Asians, wrote Varlamov.

"Ask around how things are for our Russian Yakuts, Buryats and Kalmyks -- just how respectfully people treat them in the capital of our homeland, if it's easy for them to rent an apartment, if the cops don't frisk them just because their eyes are a different shape."

Manufactured problems

Meanwhile, a similar campaign to protect supposedly victimised Russian-speaking citizens in Kazakhstan flared up after Kuat Akhmetov, a Kazakh blogger with nationalist leanings, posted videos pointing out stores and other establishments that use Russian-only signs.

Kazakh law requires business signs either to be only in Kazakh or to be bilingual.

Russians perceived Akhmetov's videos as an attempt to squeeze the Russian language out of Kazakh public life.

Konstantin Kosachev, deputy speaker of the Federation Council, Russia's upper parliamentary chamber, issued a furious rebuke.

"We must demand that Kazakh authorities assess these disgraceful actions by homegrown nationalists that have nothing in common with the neighbourly relations between our countries and peoples," Kosachev told the news agency RIA Novosti on August 11.

Like Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan took issue with the accusations coming from Moscow.

Kazakh law enforcement agencies will give "a fair legal assessment" of Akhmetov's actions, but even if such incidents occur worldwide, that "doesn't mean they're encouraged by the state or are a trend", Dauren Abayev, Kazakh President Kassym-Jomart Tokayev's first deputy chief of staff, said in an August 12 televised interview.

"Can you really judge the state of affairs in a country of 19 million people based on the inappropriate actions of two or three people? I don't think so," Abayev said.

Ninety percent of Kazakhs speak fluent Russian and one-third of Kazakh schoolchildren attend school in Russian, said Abayev, citing those statistics as evidence of the respected and essential status of the language in Kazakhstan.

Problems of bigotry in Kazakhstan are more manufactured than real, said Gaziz Abishev of Nur-Sultan, a political analyst and editor-in-chief of the Turan Times news portal.

On the other hand, jingoism and racism are widespread in Russia, where the authorities do not object to their existence, said Abishev.

"You have the right to teach others tolerance and humanity only if you yourself uphold those values ​​in practice," Abishev told Caravanserai.

Do you like this article?

24 Comment(s)

Comment Policy * Denotes Required Field 1500 / 1500

As it is impossible to imagine a circus without a clown, did the protection and safety of Russians living in Russia and CIS is left to Zhrinovsky? There is a saying in East "Dog barks, Caravan keeps going".

Reply

In Russia they treat Central Asian citizens very badly. It all starts upon arriving in Russia, meaning at the airport, and everyone knows it.

Reply

Those like Zhirinovsky should be incinerated.

Reply

THERE'S NO OPPRESSION OF RUSSIAN LANGUAGE [SPEAKERS]. THERE'S A REQUIREMENT TO RECEIVE INFORMATION IN THE NATIVE KAZAKH LANGUAGE. IT'S NATURAL. YOU PROTECT YOUR LANGUAGE, DON'T YOU? WE DO, TOO.

Reply

Bastards

Reply

Clowns only need that. They want to gain some cheap authority [in the society] since they have none of that among the population, just like Zhirik [Vladimir Zhirinovskiy], etc.

Reply

They made up everything up in Russia; they egg everybody on. It's not good...

Reply

It's clear that these court jesters (on Kremlin orders) want Russians to look the other way.

Reply

I fully agree

Reply

An important and needed article

Reply

I studied in Moscow and constantly encountered Russian jingoism. They'd do better to improve life in Russia. Because their arse is dirty with shit, but they teach others tidiness.

Reply
Comment removed for violating comments policy

What's the problem? The author writes the truth. Can Russians do something the others can't?

Reply

US CENTCOM sponsors this site.

Reply

Yes

Reply

I support this

Reply

We, Central Asian countries must get together and show Russia who we really are...

Reply

In the end of the article Gaziz Abishev said it beautifully and ended the story, I think.

Reply

The word 'ponaekhali' (came in large numbers) itself speaks volumes

Reply

This short one will soon drive a wedge between the Russian people and everyone else

Reply

The imperial ambitions of our neighbours are through the roof! Russia will end up alone in this manner; the whole world has already turned its back on them!

Reply

The people of the Baltics and Ukraine also started like that. They fought for their language and freedom. Why is nobody from the Russian higher-ups talk about them?

Reply

Russia is the centre of chauvinism in the post-Soviet realm.

Reply

Yes, migrants and even non-Russian citizens often encounter discrimination and abuse in Russia.

Reply